Sehar

Very interesting article. I was curious on the effect milk has on cookie dough going bad. If you add milk to cookie dough and store it in the fridge for a few days, will the dough remain safe to eat even after the remaining milk in the bottle has spoiled, or does the dough become unsafe at that point too?

Ashley MorrisSehar

Hi Sehar, if the milk you used in the cookie dough spoils, it does not necessarily mean that the cookie dough will become unsafe immediately, but it may impact the flavor or smell of the cookies. If the dough was mixed with fresh milk and stored properly, the cookie dough itself will generally remain safe for a short period. However, if the dough has been in the fridge for several days and the milk was already near its expiration or was spoiled when mixed, the safety of the dough could be compromised. An alternative may be to freeze whatever dough you don't plan on baking the day you make your cookie dough. Frozen dough will generally stay good for up to about 3 months while refrigerated dough should be used within 3-5 days or so. If you need further assistance, please reach out to our Customer Service Team at customerservice@bobsredmill.com.

Peter Jack

When I store my cookie dough in fridge I always wrap it with a plastic bag then a aluminum foil. In this way it stays fresh. However, I like your article that has a great source of information especially for food lovers like me. On weekend, My nieces and nephews are always ready to bake with me and we bake some yummy cookies together. Thanks Pam we love you !!!

Pam

how well does home made dough defrost? Will it effect the cookies? We like to mix up huge batches one weekend and decorate the next, but that means more than the 5 days in the fridge, but we are worried about the defrost changing the cookie flavor or texture. What is the best defrost strategy?
thank you!

Whitney BarnesPam

Hi Pam - For storing cookie dough, the freezer is a better option than the refrigerator. In the refrigerator it's more likely to absorb flavors from other food items.

Here's my favorite method: Make your cookie dough, portion out the individual cookies onto a parchment lined tray. Freeze until solid. Once solid, you can transfer the individually frozen cookie balls into an airtight container. Most cookies can be baked from frozen, they just need an extra minute or two in the oven.

If you're making roll out sugar cookies: Make your cookie dough, roll out sheets of dough to your desired thickness. The rolled out dough can then be frozen on a tray with pieces of parchment paper in between. When you're ready to cut out the cookies, remove a sheet of cookie dough and let it thaw for a few minutes, then cut out your cookies.

Natty KC

Hi : I was wondering why my homemade vegan gluten free cookie dough ends up with white spots the minute I put it in the fridge. I mix it well with an electric mixer. So not sure why. I use heat treated oat and brown rice flour and xanthim gum, canola oil, tapioca starch, water.. as well as the other typical ingredients. Does this mean it went bad even though I covered it and placed it in the fridge not too long ago?

Whitney BarnesNatty KC

Hi! It's difficult to say what happening here without being in your kitchen, but I'd guess that the xanthan gum or tapioca starch is gelling with the liquid and forming the white spots. I'd suggest whisking all of the dry ingredients together first before adding any wet ingredients, this will ensure that the xanthan gum and starches are well dispersed throughout the flour. If you need more assistance, feel free to email us at CustomerService@bobsredmill.com or give us a call at 1-800-349-2173.

Debra Lynn Ross

I froze logs of homemade cookie dough, slice and bake, for two weeks and defrosted in the refrigerator, which is 37 degrees. How long can I keep the defrosted dough in the refrigerator once it has defrosted? Thanks for your help!!

Whitney BarnesDebra Lynn Ross

Hi Debra - 3-5 days in the refrigerator. Overtime the cookie dough will lose moisture, pick up flavors/scents from other items in your refrigerator, and the leavening agents (baking powder or baking soda) may lose their potency.

Dawn M Bridson

Thanks so much! This is so helpful. I appreciate the concise, straightforward approach with directions and this was perfect. Happy Holidays!

Sandy

Very well written and informative article. Thank you so much.
Stay happy & well.